Featured / Philadelphia Soccer History

Why Bethlehem Steel FC?

Now that the Philadelphia Union’s third kit has officially been unveiled, I want to take a moment to answer a question many of you might be asking yourself.

Why Bethlehem Steel?

History is the foundation of the present

The guiding design concept behind the the new kit is that the Union’s existence is built upon a foundation that, in addition to the fans, includes the Philadelphia area’s rich soccer history.

It wasn’t very long after the formalization of the rules of the game in 1863 before expats and others were playing soccer in and around Philadelphia. Neighborhood athletic associations and ethnic clubs, Philadelphia’s cricket clubs, students—are all examples of those who played the game before the city’s first formal league, the Pennsylvania Football Union, was organized in 1889. Incidentally, two of the founding teams of the PFU were the Chester Volunteers and the Eddystones so the Union’s roots in the foundation of Philadelphia soccer history can be said to involve not just their name but also the area around PPL Park.

But why Bethlehem Steel and not teams like the ASL champion Philadelphia Nationals or Philadelphia Americans? Why not the Ukrainian Nationals, who dominated in the ASL and in US Open Cup play during the first half of the 1960s? Why not the Philadelphia Atoms? This year marks the 40th anniversary of their NASL championship inaugural season and they even wore adidas kits in 1973.

Why Bethlehem Steel, a team that is 69 miles from Philadelphia?

The answer is quite simple: Bethlehem Steel FC’s history, just like the teams mentioned above and many more, is a part of Philadelphia’s soccer history.

Bethlehem Steel FC is part of Philadelphia’s soccer history

In August of 1911, Bethlehem joined the newly formed Eastern Pennsylvania League, composed of teams from Reading, Harrisburg, Lancaster, Lansford and Summit Hill. After trotting undefeated through that first season Bethlehem FC naturally looked to Philadelphia greater challenges.

As early as 1908, Bethlehem FC was playing exhibition games against teams from the Philadelphia League. In February of 1912, the club joined Philadelphia’s Allied Amateur Football Association in order to participate in the association’s annual Allied Amateur Cup tournament, which that year kicked off in March, just as the Union’s season does. Bethlehem made it to the tournament final only to lose 3–1 to Upper Darby’s Cardington FC.

In August of 1912, the team joined the first division of Philadelphia’s newly formed Allied American Football Association. While with the AAFA, Bethlehem would win the league championship two consecutive seasons as well as the city’s Allied Cup tournament and the first of six American Cup championships.

Bethlehem moved to Philadelphia’s American League of Association Football Clubs for the 1914-15 season. With a team made up of what the 1915 Spalding Guide described as “practically the cream of Philadelphia soccer players,” Bethlehem won the league championship that season and their first US Open Cup, then known as the National Challenge Cup.

For the 1915-16 season, Bethlehem joined the American League of Philadelphia. While they finished second in league play, that season they became the first club to win the American Cup and the US Open Cup in the same year.

In other words, Bethlehem’s emergence as a legend of American soccer begins with the club joining Philadelphia-based leagues. From the AAFA cup tournament in the spring of 1912 through the spring of 1916 in the ALP, Bethlehem won three Philadelphia-based league championships, finishing second the only season they were not champions, and one Allied Amateur Cup. During that time they also won two of their six American Cup titles and two of their five US Open Cup titles. By the time Bethlehem withdrew from league play for the 1916-17 season to focus on cup tournament play and exhibition games, their legend was firmly established, locally and across the country.

When Bethlehem joined the semi-professional National Association Football League for the first of four seasons in 1917—where in addition to winning three consecutive league championships after finishing in second place that first season the club also claimed both the American Cup and US Open Cup championship’s two more times—they were joined by another storied Philadelphia team, Disston. Before becoming Disston ahead of the 1914-15 season—the same season Bethlehem FC became Bethlehem Steel FC—the team had won the 1910 American Cup playing as Tacony FC, Tacony being the de facto company town of the Disston Saw Works. Bethlehem had defeated Tacony for its first American Cup title in 1914, handing the Sawmakers their second American Cup final loss in a row.

Bethlehem as Philadelphia FC

When the American Soccer League began in 1921, the league wanted a team to be based in Philadelphia. Bethlehem Steel became that team, playing as the Philadelphia Field Club for the 1921-22 season. They won the inaugural ASL championship before returning to Bethlehem the next season. Following their season in the ASL as Philadelphia FC and until the club’s demise in 1930, Bethlehem would record four second place finishes in the ASL, one ASL championship, two Eastern Soccer League championships, one Lewis Cup championship, one American Cup championship, and one US Open Cup championship.

Who and why

Who were Bethlehem Steel? One of the most successful teams in the history of soccer in the United States.

Why Bethlehem Steel? Because their history is part of the long history of soccer in the Philadelphia area.

Setting aside Bethlehem Steel’s accomplishments for a moment to give you another sense of that history, in the half century between 1923 and 1973, Philadelphia teams won one American Cup, five US Open Cups, five National Amateur Cups, and five McGuire Cups. In league play, there were 17 ASL championships and one NASL championship.

Then, as always, these champions played alongside teams who finished second, or third, or last, and whose only abiding reward may have been little more than the love of the game. As the living legacy of all these teams, the Union will continue their own chapter in that history when they open the season at PPL Park this Saturday at 4pm.

Whether the new third kit marks the beginning of a Union tradition of honoring Philadelphia’s soccer history through their jerseys remains to be seen, but I honor the club’s acknowledgement that its own emerging history rests on a foundation laid by those who preceded them in the long history of soccer in the Philadelphia area.

The Union have embraced Philadelphia’s soccer history and you should too—whether you have ever played the game, coached, reffed, volunteered, been the driver, or simply support the Union or one of the many past or present area teams— you are part of that history.

Which is to say that history also belongs to you.

 

19 Comments

  1. This forced history nonsense is annoying. If you have to go to this length to explain how these two teams are related then you know the issue is being forced. Like the look of the new jerseys but the connection is a reach.

    • You know what’s annoying? Negative Nancy’s like you.

    • Ed Farnsworth says:

      I went to “this length” because I’m assuming most Philadelphia Union fans don’t know much about BSFC. I also went to “this length” because the connections are, you know, lengthy.

    • let’s all do union inaugural season throwbacks! ’cause, you know, the link to them is solid…

    • let’s all don union inaugural season throwbacks! ’cause, you know, the link to them is solid…

    • Uhhh I don’t really get the argument. The connection is quite simple. Bethlehem Steep is a local team with a winning tradition, The Union are a local team who want to honor and be associated with that history.
      As US Soccer tried to gain a permanent foothold in America history is a good way to help traditions take hold, such as the Gold Cup ect ect.

      • If it were up to me it would have Tacony FC but I think the Union front office have lost my number.

      • In this case, local is a relative term. Personally, I wouldn’t call them a local team, even if they did participate in numerous Philadelphia-based leagues. That said, they are still a part of Philadelphia soccer history, and, more importantly, an important part of US soccer history.

  2. Well written and informative. Excellent article Ed thank you very much I enjoyed it immensely .

  3. Being from bethlehem and knowing the history, it’s great to see its honored still today. The union are linking themselves w a winning tradition that was the inception of US soccer which totally makes sense. Kudos Ed on the great article…too bad that people are ignorant to the history lesson

  4. I find this look back fascinating, and thanks for the trip. My grandfather died when I was ten months old, but he played soccer for a team that was based at Stetson School in Philadelphia. Soccer was an unusual sport when I started to play, and it was amazing to me to learn that there was a history of the game in Philadelphia that dated back to the early part of the 20th century. I heard from my grandmother about how my grandfather wanted to play for Bethlehem Steel when he grew up. Your story put that in context; he was wishing the same way that kids today want to play in the majors. Archie Stark forever!

  5. I was kind of hoping they’d do a throwback to the Atoms, though Bethlehem Steel is just as good, if not better. :)

  6. My Grandmothers brother Fred Pepper played for Bethlehem Steel and I have his 1914-15 winners medal. Does anyone know any history of his playing days in the US. One story about him that I know is that he cancelled his passage on the Titanic and came out on another ship.

  7. A lot of thanks for all your labor on this blog. Debby takes plruease in working on research and it is easy to see why. A number of us know all regarding the compelling manner you offer precious solutions on the blog and in addition boost response from others on the subject matter while our own daughter is actually discovering a whole lot. Take plruease in the rest of the new year. You’re doing a really great job.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>